Planning Primer
Building a Model for Internal Growth
The Bridge of Life (above, top), a museum of
biodiversity being constructed in Panama, will tell
the story of life itself. Designed by world-renowned
architect Frank O. Gehry, the building will be located
on the Pacific entrance to the Panama Canal. It will
be nestled between Panama City, the ocean and the
rainforest. Products from Euclid Chemical and Tremco
will provide waterproofing to various aspects of the
unique structure.
Building on successful prior advertising initiatives
(above, lower), Rust-Oleum, DAP and Zinsser will rely
on creative television advertisements to introduce new
products to consumers and drive sales.
by guest columnist
Ronald A. Rice
Executive Vice President and
Chief Operating Officer
For the past several years, RPM’s organic
growth has been about three times the
average growth rate of the coatings industry,
which pretty much mirrors overall economic
growth. This has not happened by accident,
but rather through a rigorous planning
process that is ingrained in the RPM culture,
and involves separate business plans for nearly
50 operating units.
Fiscal 2009 marks the 30th year since formal
planning was initiated at RPM, at the
instigation of three outside directors of the
then-$100 million dollar company. For much
of that time, internal growth plans were very
conservative, short-term oriented and very
much bottom-line focused.
Certain hallmarks of early plans remain
integral to the process today, including:
- A “no surprises” culture and the
establishment of a platform for ongoing
and frequent communication between
operating units and the corporate office;
- Development of a tiered plan, whereby
pre-determined actions occur immediately
if profit targets are missed;
- A “bottom-up” process where those
responsible for developing the plan are also
responsible for its execution;
- Arriving at goals that are mutually
agreeable and commonly shared by
the operating unit and the corporate
office; and,
- Planning down to the business unit level,
where unique, smaller entrepreneurial
businesses don’t get lost within larger
operating platforms.
Above all, the key to the successful
process has been a culture where
the plan commitment is of paramount
importance. As a result,
- Prior to commencement of plan year,
much analytical work is required to
ensure that the many assumptions
providing the foundation to the detailed
plan are realistic, not too conservative nor
overly optimistic.
- During the plan year, management
maintains a “laser-like” focus on meeting
plan. While industry and economic
conditions change, the plan doesn’t. Thus,
operating management must react swiftly
in order to succeed.
Revenue Growth Added to
Traditional Bottom-Line Focus
At RPM, the primary purpose of planning is
to successfully identify and implement solid
investment opportunities. Of course, one of
the main objectives of budgeting is to control
spending, and this is a daily focus throughout
the company. However, our planning process
has evolved to a more balanced approach
that better fosters long-term internal growth
by avoiding “self-liquidation” of our highpotential
businesses.
In the spring of 2000, RPM conducted our
first Growth & Strategy Conference, where
we broadened the planning process to address
new market opportunities in addition to
the customary and continuing emphasis on
bottom-line results. This conference has since
been expanded into a two-week long series
of meetings with operating companies where
they present their ideas for revenue growth to
both corporate leaders and other operating
company executives, and seek funding for
these initiatives. Through the Growth &
Strategy Conferences, we also identify the
most important growth initiatives, directly
link them into our planning process and
protect them from spending cuts should
these be warranted by deteriorating
economic conditions.
Tremco made history with the installation of the only
vegetated roof system on a presidential library in
the United States. Created for the William J. Clinton
Presidential Library in Little Rock, AR,
the roof’s insulating properties and ability to reuse
rainwater reduce the building’s energy usage.
Historically, RPM had been more aggressive
in acquisitions than it had been in developing
organic growth opportunities. We now
recognize that a well-conceived internal
growth investment can have equal, if not
greater, value to RPM than a well-planned
acquisition of a new company or product
line. Critical components of the internal
growth process include analyzing the market
dynamics and competitive landscape of the
opportunity, as well as evaluating spending
needs and associated returns. At the same
time, we foster inter-company cooperation in
manufacturing, purchasing and information
sharing, which assists in funding growth.
Outcomes Boost Top and Bottom Line
At about the same time as the Growth
& Strategy conferences began, we also
introduced a new form of operating company
management incentive designed to reward
incremental growth, called CANE (capital
adjusted net earnings). Rather than evaluating
business unit performance on operating
profit alone, we also look at the cost of capital
associated with developing that operating
profit. As a result, the planning process at
RPM reinforces our traditional bottom linemindset,
but at the same time incorporates a
cost of capital component into it.
Two “home runs” resulting from this process
include Tremco’s roofing services business
and Rust-Oleum’s garage and basement floor
coating business, EpoxyShield. These two
businesses produced more than $250 million
of profitable revenue for RPM in fiscal 2008
from a miniscule base five years ago. Another
“home run” from a Growth & Strategy
investment is Euclid Chemical’s geographic
expansion, which has been instrumental
in doubling Euclid’s sales over the last
four years.
Other growth initiatives involve investing
in a strengthened sales and service capability.
For example, most of our industrial
businesses have direct sales forces that
are extremely knowledgeable about their
products and perform after-sale services as
well. Two years ago, Stonhard came to the
Growth & Strategy sessions with the idea
of creating a construction management
group to oversee installations on big jobs,
thereby freeing up its direct sales force to do
more selling, versus providing the necessary
oversight on current projects. The result has
been a sharp boost in Stonhard sales and
an increase in customer satisfaction. The
combination of long-standing relationships, a
knowledgeable sales force and more efficient
project management equates to an even
stronger competitive advantage. This program
has had such great success that we are in the
process of rolling it out to other appropriate
industrial business units, both in the U.S.
and Europe.
With our consumer businesses, we have seen
the tremendous sales impact that television
advertising, properly planned and executed,
can bring, assuming we have the distribution
in place to support it. Rust-Oleum, DAP and
Zinsser are all investing heavily in increased
television ad schedules to support both new
innovations and existing products. Although
many parts of the consumer market are weak
right now, we know that we are gaining
market share in sizeable increments, and
in categories where flat or declining sales
presently exist, our performance is well above
the competition.
Fundamental to RPM’s performance is
a culture of growth, the key element of
which is our planning process. It is via this
process that RPM is able to manage a global,
decentralized organization with a small
corporate staff, thereby maintaining our
unique entrepreneurial operating philosophy,
which is critical to our continued success.